dialog Gulag Archipelago
25 March 06
Alex is a second generation German-Jews( 750000 of them emigrated to SovietUnion ) and certainly hardcore Marxist, but fortunately(or unfortunately ) send to the home front and survive, unlike 95% of his peers that perished in WW2
This Gulag-Reeducation camp never kills people without cause like their Nazi counterparts; I am sorry to said that but they both possesed a German-frame-of-mind....remember that Karl Marx was writing German Idealogy......:)
Stalin was a hero of his people because he saved his country from German-Nazi.......
One more thing; Soviet army has taken German POW around 3000000 person; where are they?
Dead in Gulag camp?
Sure a couple of ex POW could manage to get home in the 50s, but all of them at the rank of General,colonel,leutenant or simply the elite bourgeois;
the rest of them, millions of foot-soldier,ex corporal,ex seargent never got back after years of hard labor....
Where r they? Never been noticed by bourgeois historian?
They simply mingled into Russian society, married so many Russian girls( boys mostly dead remember ) n change their name n language into Soviet Russian culture....
So do not blame Stalin to the Soviet people....he really build a proletariat Glory......
Mar 24, 2006 11:09 AM Flag spam/abuse. [ ? ]
Subject: RE: Hi.......
Body: Its hard to say. He would probably find it very hard to say himself. i have no doubt that he loved the ideal of communism but he certainly suffered at its hands in practice.
i think he was a Marxist and probably, deep down, still loved marxism, but certainly was no fan of Stalinism. he loved the idea that the real proletariat can rule and was willing to suffer for his beliefs, which shows a will that may be strong enough to foster his true passions and therefore keep his love alive.
In truth, I dont really know.
you are the first person to ask me about that on this mp space thingy.
Take care
Vince
----------------- Original Message -----------------
From: Ricci
Date: Mar 24, 2006 12:54 AM
After you read Gulag archipelago.....
do you think that Alex Solzhenitsyn love real communism or not?
Alex is a second generation German-Jews( 750000 of them emigrated to SovietUnion ) and certainly hardcore Marxist, but fortunately(or unfortunately ) send to the home front and survive, unlike 95% of his peers that perished in WW2
This Gulag-Reeducation camp never kills people without cause like their Nazi counterparts; I am sorry to said that but they both possesed a German-frame-of-mind....remember that Karl Marx was writing German Idealogy......:)
Stalin was a hero of his people because he saved his country from German-Nazi.......
One more thing; Soviet army has taken German POW around 3000000 person; where are they?
Dead in Gulag camp?
Sure a couple of ex POW could manage to get home in the 50s, but all of them at the rank of General,colonel,leutenant or simply the elite bourgeois;
the rest of them, millions of foot-soldier,ex corporal,ex seargent never got back after years of hard labor....
Where r they? Never been noticed by bourgeois historian?
They simply mingled into Russian society, married so many Russian girls( boys mostly dead remember ) n change their name n language into Soviet Russian culture....
So do not blame Stalin to the Soviet people....he really build a proletariat Glory......
Mar 24, 2006 11:09 AM Flag spam/abuse. [ ? ]
Subject: RE: Hi.......
Body: Its hard to say. He would probably find it very hard to say himself. i have no doubt that he loved the ideal of communism but he certainly suffered at its hands in practice.
i think he was a Marxist and probably, deep down, still loved marxism, but certainly was no fan of Stalinism. he loved the idea that the real proletariat can rule and was willing to suffer for his beliefs, which shows a will that may be strong enough to foster his true passions and therefore keep his love alive.
In truth, I dont really know.
you are the first person to ask me about that on this mp space thingy.
Take care
Vince
----------------- Original Message -----------------
From: Ricci
Date: Mar 24, 2006 12:54 AM
After you read Gulag archipelago.....
do you think that Alex Solzhenitsyn love real communism or not?
posted by Reqiyaqereh @ 12:18 AM
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home